Not all fishways are created equal (#60)
Around the world, many fishways have been constructed to provide a route
for upstream migrating fish to pass dams.
Most were designed for salmon, but other species have
also been targeted. While sometimes
successful, often these fishways are not, because they were constructed with
insufficient hydraulic and biological knowledge about the target species, or
were installed in locations or with insufficient attraction flow for them to be
effective. The hydraulics of several
fishway types have been well studied, but they lack sufficient biological
knowledge for how many species will respond to the hydraulics within them. Not surprisingly, in some of these fishways
some species can successfully pass, but some species cannot. Results of evaluations indicate that when
sufficient hydraulic and biological knowledge exists for a species, it is
possible to construct successful fishways.
This requires knowing how behaviour and swimming abilities interact with
hydraulic conditions in different fishway configurations. This type of
information is crucial to the development of fishways that have the best chance
of being effective. There are different
ways to monitor fish movements and evaluate fishway effectiveness, using fairly
simple to fairly sophisticated methods.
Fishway evaluations have evolved as animal tracking technology
developed, from simple observations on fish numbers, to state-of-the-art
physiological measures, including heart rate and stress level. Although it is not always feasible to use the
latest technology, scientific assessment information is needed for many
species, as fishway science continues to advance to hopefully one day create
fishways that all species can successfully pass.